Buying Gifts and Toys: Make Sure They're Safe
Everyone who sells products has to follow several legal requirements – for example, copyright laws (not making copies of Disney characters), paying taxes, business insurance, etc – you know, the good stuff!
However there is one area, in particular, that should never be compromised on but, unfortunately, often is.
And that is safety testing.
And this safety testing is applied to ALL businesses and ALL products (yes, even small businesses and side hustles) with the testing becoming even more rigorous around items for children, such as toys and anything that could be seen to have a play value for children.
(Think about it – any item that has play value for a child? Keyrings? Bag charms? Cushions or sleeping bags in the form of characters or animals?)
Why wouldn’t it be? Why wouldn’t you want the things you buy for your children to be as safe as possible, wherever you buy them from?
Since 2016, when I started selling my crocheted items, the safety of the items I make is important to me and has even shaped what I will and won’t sell in my business. To me, taking a risk with the safety of an item just isn’t worth it.
Over the past 3 years, I have attended many craft fairs, and without fail, at every single event, there is a trader selling items that should be safety tested but aren’t.
Whether this is through innocent ignorance or a knowing dismissal of the legal requirements is irrelevant.
And, by the way, writing ‘Not suitable for children under the age of 3’ on your labels IS NOT GOOD ENOUGH.
If you want to take the risk of selling copyrighted items (including things like Gonks and the ‘Positive Potato’) and you get caught, taken to court and pay a huge fine that could be a devastating amount for you to pay (Disney will sue you for millions) – you make the choice and face the consequences.
But if you choose to ignore safety testing?
I mean, it’s just “health and safety gone mad!” right? Right?!
Let’s Look at Some Stats
The BTHA (British Toy & Hobby Association) represent around 80% of the toy manufacturers and sellers in the UK with members voluntarily signing up to a code of practice covering the safety of the toys made and sold. They also take this slightly further and members have to, not only be safe but also ethical, market their toys responsibly, and be committed to improving their sustainability.
Part of the BTHA’s work is to monitor the whole marketplace for toys within Britain, including online, and in their recent report (Still Toying with Children’s Safety, 2024) they found that 85% of the toys they purchased and tested were unsafe and posed a risk to children.
EIGHTY-FIVE PER CENT
And did you know that in the UK, online marketplaces have no legal responsibility for the safety of the toys sold on their platforms by third-party sellers?
Mind. Blown.
Toy Industries of Europe (TIE) took this further in February 2024 by focusing their testing on the online platform Temu.
What per cent of the toys they bought and tested on Temu do you think failed the safety tests?
a. 80%
b. 68%
c. 95%
The correct answer is c – 95%.
But even worse than that is that none of the toys bought from Temu complied with any EU toy safety legislation.
None. Zero. Nada. Zilch. Bugger all.
In fact they shouldn’t even be on sale in the EU.
These are just some of the dangers TIE found:
-
-
-
- Chemical danger – Boron (boron?!?!) migrating from a ‘slime kit’ was found to be 11 times higher than the legal limit for toys.
- Cutting and punctures from sharp edges
- Blockage and choking hazards from small parts and protrusions
- Strangulation
- Catching fire – The Crocodile Story
-
-
Think about this though – TIE’s research only included 19 products. Do you reckon that the rest of the products sold on sites like Temu are safer? Or not?
From October 2021 to September 2021, the UK Government’s Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS) tested 2,260 products of all types from online marketplaces.
Out of these, 1832 (81%) failed with the largest number of failures coming from the category . . . .
Bueller.
Bueller.
Yep, toys.
The Chartered Trading Standards Institute (CTSI) “is concerned about the overwhelmingly high rate of 81% non-compliance demonstrating that online marketplaces are still flooding the UK with unsafe goods and posing serious risks to UK consumers.” and that the “UK has become a dumping ground for unsafe products.“
Regulations and Standards: What We All Need to Know
Sellers must be aware of the various regulations and standards that apply to their products in the country they sell them. This includes understanding local, national, and international safety standards, which can differ significantly.
For example, in the United States, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) sets guidelines for product safety.
In the European Union, the CE marking indicates compliance with stringent safety standards, along with the new GSPR (General Safety and Performance Requirements) if you are based in Great Britain and sell to the EU or Northern Ireland.
If you are selling within Great Britain (England, Scotland & Wales), there is the UKCA (United Kingdom Conformity Assessment) testing and marking system. If you sell to Northern Ireland or the EU, you have to follow CE marking regulations.
(NB: All of these regulations for selling goods within Great Britain are built on the foundation of the General Product Safety Regulations 2005 which apply to ALL goods sold within GB – not just toys)
Whichever country you sell to, you must understand and comply with the relevant safety legislation that applies there.
The Risks of Not Safety Testing
As previously stated, skipping safety testing can lead to serious consequences for both sellers and consumers. For sellers, the financial and reputational damage from selling unsafe products can be devastating. Legal actions, product recalls, and negative publicity are just a few of the potential outcomes.
For consumers, the risks are even more dire. Unsafe products can cause injuries, health issues, or even fatalities. In the case of crocheted items, improper materials or construction methods can lead to choking hazards, allergic reactions, or other safety concerns, particularly for children.
What Can Buyers Do?
Buyers also play a crucial role in promoting product safety. By being informed and vigilant, consumers can help ensure they are purchasing safe products. This includes;
- looking for safety certifications
- reading product reviews
- asking sellers about their safety testing procedures
Additionally, buyers can report unsafe products to regulatory bodies, which can help prevent others from being exposed to potential hazards.
The BTHA give these five tips for buying online:
- Be more careful about buying from third-party sellers on online marketplaces – don’t assume that any safety tests have been carried out.
- Make time to research the toy before you buy. If purchasing a branded product, compare the toy against the company’s own website.
- Be careful of going for the cheapest price, check who the seller is, do they have a good track record of selling toys, and see which country they are based in.
- Once you receive your toy, see if the packaging looks genuine, and check if it has a UK address as well as looking for a CE or UKCA mark.
- When your child opens a toy, stay with them and check for faults, detachable small parts, access to stuffing and loose or accessible batteries or magnets.
Be safe out there ![]()
PS: If you’re a UK business and want to start testing your toys, this group on Facebook is a must.
